8+ Cello Suzuki Book 2 PDFs (Free Download)


8+ Cello Suzuki Book 2 PDFs (Free Download)

The second quantity in a famend collection of pedagogical supplies for starting cellists presents a curated choice of musical items, sometimes from the Baroque and Classical intervals. These progressively difficult works construct upon the foundational expertise launched within the first quantity, incorporating new strategies and musical ideas. Digital variations of this quantity provide handy entry and portability.

This core textual content supplies a structured studying pathway, fostering musicality and technical proficiency in younger musicians. Its widespread adoption in music schooling underscores its effectiveness in creating a stable basis for aspiring cellists. The structured curriculum, rooted in a philosophy of immersion and parental involvement, contributes to a optimistic and enriching studying expertise.

Additional exploration will delve into particular features of this instructional useful resource, together with its pedagogical method, musical content material, and sensible functions for each college students and educators. An in depth evaluation of the items included and the technical expertise addressed will present useful insights for these using this materials.

1. Digital Sheet Music

Digital sheet music performs an important function in fashionable music schooling, providing quite a few benefits over conventional printed codecs. Within the context of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, the supply of digital variations considerably enhances accessibility and studying alternatives. This format permits for higher flexibility and integration with expertise, benefiting each college students and educators.

  • Portability and Accessibility

    Digital variations, significantly in PDF format, provide unparalleled portability. College students can entry their music on numerous gadgets, eliminating the necessity for cumbersome bodily books. This comfort promotes constant follow, no matter location. Moreover, digital codecs will be simply shared with academics or collaborators, facilitating distant studying and suggestions.

  • Annotation and Markup

    Digital sheet music allows college students and academics to annotate scores instantly. Including fingerings, bowings, and different markings instantly onto the music facilitates studying and understanding. These digital annotations will be saved, modified, and shared, providing a dynamic and interactive studying expertise in comparison with conventional pencil markings on bodily copies.

  • Integration with Expertise

    Digital scores will be built-in with music software program and functions, permitting college students to make the most of instruments equivalent to metronomes, tuners, and playback options. This integration fosters self-directed studying and permits for deeper engagement with the music. Moreover, digital sheet music will be simply transposed, adjusted for various display screen sizes, and optimized for particular person studying preferences.

  • Value-Effectiveness and Environmental Affect

    Digital variations usually provide a more cost effective different to printed supplies, particularly contemplating the potential for loss or injury of bodily books. Moreover, choosing digital sources contributes to a discount in paper consumption, aligning with environmentally aware practices. This sustainability side provides one other layer of profit to picking digital codecs.

The mixing of digital sheet music, exemplified by the supply of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 in PDF format, represents a big development in music schooling. The aforementioned sides contribute to a richer, extra accessible, and customized studying expertise, empowering college students and educators alike.

2. Suzuki Methodology

The Suzuki Methodology types the pedagogical basis upon which the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, together with its digital PDF model, is constructed. Understanding the core tenets of this methodology is essential for successfully using the fabric and attaining its meant studying outcomes. This methodology emphasizes a holistic method to music schooling, drawing parallels with language acquisition and fostering a nurturing studying atmosphere.

  • Mum or dad Involvement

    Parental involvement is a cornerstone of the Suzuki Methodology. Dad and mom attend classes, act as house follow companions, and create a supportive musical atmosphere. This lively participation reinforces studying and strengthens the parent-child bond. Throughout the context of the Cello Guide 2, dad and mom play an important function in guiding follow classes, making certain constant engagement with the fabric.

  • Early Starting

    The Suzuki Methodology encourages an early begin to musical coaching, usually starting at a younger age. Much like language acquisition, early publicity to music is believed to foster pure studying and growth. Whereas the Cello Guide 2 is not meant for absolutely the newbie, it builds upon the foundational expertise established in earlier phases of Suzuki coaching, reinforcing the significance of a sequential studying course of.

  • Listening and Repetition

    Listening to recordings of the items within the Suzuki repertoire, together with these in Cello Guide 2, is taken into account important. Repeated listening familiarizes college students with the music earlier than they start taking part in, fostering aural growth and musicality. This aural immersion, coupled with repetitive follow, facilitates internalization of the musical language and technical expertise.

  • Group Classes and Efficiency

    Group classes and efficiency alternatives are integral parts of the Suzuki Methodology, offering motivation, peer studying, and a way of group. College students utilizing Cello Guide 2 usually take part in group lessons and performances, fostering collaboration and constructing confidence. This shared studying expertise enhances the person studying course of and contributes to a optimistic musical atmosphere.

The Suzuki Cello Guide 2 PDF, as a digital illustration of the curriculum, serves as a software throughout the broader framework of the Suzuki Methodology. By understanding these core rules, college students and fogeys can maximize the advantages of this useful resource and domesticate a lifelong love of music and the cello. This holistic method, emphasizing parental involvement, early publicity, listening, and group studying, distinguishes the Suzuki Methodology and shapes the educational expertise related to its related supplies.

3. Cello Approach

Technical proficiency types the bedrock of musical expression on the cello. The Suzuki Cello Guide 2, whether or not in bodily or digital PDF format, serves as a automobile for creating important cello strategies. This quantity builds upon the foundational expertise launched within the first e-book, introducing new challenges and refining present ones. Understanding the technical features addressed inside this quantity is essential for each college students and educators.

  • Bow Management and Articulation

    Guide 2 introduces more and more advanced bowing patterns and articulations, equivalent to dtach, staccato, and legato. These strategies are important for shaping musical phrases and conveying nuanced expression. Mastery of those bowing strategies is facilitated by the fastidiously chosen items throughout the e-book, which give sensible utility and progressive growth. Examples embrace the managed use of the bow for clean transitions between notes in legato passages and the exact, brief bow strokes required for staccato articulation.

  • Left-Hand Dexterity and Intonation

    Creating correct intonation and agile left-hand method is paramount in cello taking part in. Guide 2 introduces new finger patterns, shifting, and extensions, difficult college students to refine their finger placement and coordination. This progressive growth of left-hand dexterity is important for taking part in more and more advanced melodic passages and attaining correct pitch. Examples embrace practising scales and arpeggios to enhance finger dexterity and ear coaching workouts to develop correct intonation.

  • String Crossings and Shifting

    Easy and seamless string crossings are essential for sustaining a constant tone and musical circulation. Guide 2 introduces extra superior string crossing patterns, requiring exact bow management and left-hand coordination. Equally, shifting between positions turns into extra prevalent, demanding correct finger placement and clean transitions. Practising these transitions slowly and intentionally is important for creating proficiency and musicality.

  • Vibrato and Tone Manufacturing

    Whereas vibrato may not be explicitly launched in Guide 2 for all college students, the inspiration for its growth begins with a deal with tone manufacturing. The items on this quantity encourage a wealthy, resonant tone, laying the groundwork for future vibrato growth. Constant follow and a focus to bow strain and pace contribute to a wonderful tone and supply a foundation for expressive vibrato in a while. Workout routines specializing in lengthy, sustained notes will help develop a constant and managed tone.

See also  6+ Best Buddha Bowl Recipe Books for Beginners

The technical expertise cultivated within the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 usually are not merely workouts; they’re integral to musical expression. By mastering these strategies, college students develop the instruments essential to convey the nuances and feelings embedded throughout the music. This emphasis on technical growth, coupled with the fastidiously curated repertoire, prepares college students for continued development and exploration of the cello’s expressive potential.

4. Guide 2 Repertoire

The repertoire comprising the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, usually accessed right now by means of digital PDF variations, types the core studying materials for college kids at this stage of their growth. Cautious choice and sequencing of those items present a structured pathway for technical and musical development. Inspecting particular parts of this repertoire reveals its pedagogical worth and contribution to the general studying expertise.

  • People Songs and Conventional Melodies

    Many items in Guide 2 draw from people tune traditions and acquainted melodies. These accessible and sometimes participating items present a snug entry level for college kids, fostering enjoyment and motivation. Examples embrace “Flippantly Row,” “Go Inform Aunt Rhody,” and “Lengthy, Lengthy In the past.” These acquainted tunes present a relatable context for studying new technical expertise, making the educational course of extra pleasing and fewer daunting.

  • Graded Development of Problem

    The items inside Guide 2 are meticulously sequenced, presenting progressively rising technical challenges. This graded method ensures that college students construct upon beforehand acquired expertise, creating their skills systematically. For instance, earlier items may deal with easy bowing patterns and finger placements, whereas later items introduce extra advanced rhythms, string crossings, and shifting. This structured development permits for regular and constant development.

  • Introduction to Stylistic Parts

    Whereas primarily specializing in Baroque and Classical intervals, Guide 2 begins to introduce college students to varied stylistic components. Items by composers equivalent to Bach, Handel, and Vivaldi expose college students to elementary musical types and stylistic traits. This early publicity lays the groundwork for a deeper understanding and appreciation of numerous musical types later of their research.

  • Creating Musicality and Expression

    Past technical growth, Guide 2 encourages musicality and expression. Whereas specializing in technical accuracy is important, the repertoire additionally supplies alternatives for college kids to discover dynamics, phrasing, and articulation, fostering musical interpretation and private expression. This emphasis on musicality ensures that technical growth serves the final word purpose of inventive communication.

The repertoire of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, accessible by means of handy digital PDFs, constitutes greater than only a assortment of items; it represents a fastidiously designed curriculum. The choice and sequencing of those works, incorporating people songs, graded problem, stylistic components, and alternatives for musical expression, contribute considerably to the coed’s general musical growth. This curated assortment supplies a structured pathway for development, fostering technical proficiency and nurturing inventive sensibility throughout the framework of the Suzuki Methodology.

5. PDF Accessibility

PDF accessibility, within the context of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, considerably impacts its usability and attain. A correctly formatted PDF model ensures that the musical notation, follow directions, and accompanying textual content are available to all customers, together with these with disabilities. This accessibility broadens the potential viewers and promotes inclusivity inside music schooling. Components equivalent to text-based musical notation, display screen reader compatibility, and adjustable font sizes contribute to an accessible and user-friendly expertise. For college students with visible impairments, a display screen reader can convert the musical notation and textual content into audio output, enabling unbiased studying. Adjustable font sizes accommodate various visible wants, making certain comfy studying and follow for all customers.

The sensible significance of PDF accessibility extends past particular person customers. Music educators profit from accessible supplies, enabling them to cater to numerous studying wants inside their lecture rooms. Establishments and organizations selling music schooling can leverage accessible digital sources to broaden their attain and affect. For instance, a music college can make the most of accessible PDF variations of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 to supply on-line programs or distant studying alternatives, reaching college students in geographically numerous places or these with mobility limitations. Moreover, accessible digital sources will be simply archived and preserved, making certain long-term availability and contributing to the preservation of musical heritage.

Making certain PDF accessibility for supplies just like the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 requires adherence to established accessibility tips. This includes structuring the doc logically, utilizing acceptable tags and metadata, and offering different textual content descriptions for photographs and non-text components. Whereas technical concerns are important, the overarching purpose is to create an inclusive studying atmosphere the place all people can entry and profit from high-quality music schooling sources. Addressing accessibility challenges contributes to a extra equitable and enriching studying expertise for all aspiring cellists.

6. Apply Methods

Efficient follow methods are important for maximizing the educational potential embedded throughout the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, particularly when using the digital PDF model. These methods present a structured method to studying the repertoire and creating the mandatory technical expertise. Methodical follow, knowledgeable by pedagogical rules, transforms the educational course of from rote repetition right into a journey of musical discovery and technical mastery.

  • Purpose-Oriented Apply

    Defining particular, achievable objectives for every follow session supplies path and focus. Somewhat than merely taking part in by means of items, college students ought to establish particular technical challenges or musical passages that require consideration. For instance, a scholar may deal with enhancing the intonation of a selected passage in a Bach minuet or refining the bow articulation in a people tune. This focused method, facilitated by the readily accessible nature of the digital PDF, ensures environment friendly and productive follow classes.

  • Gradual and Deliberate Apply

    Practising at slower tempos permits for targeted consideration on technical particulars and correct execution. This deliberate method builds a stable basis, making certain that technical challenges are addressed earlier than rising pace. The digital format permits college students to make the most of playback options and looping capabilities to isolate particular passages for repeated follow, facilitating the event of muscle reminiscence and technical precision. Gradual follow additionally supplies a possibility to research the musical construction and phrasing of a chunk, fostering a deeper understanding of its inventive content material.

  • Repetition and Reinforcement

    Repetition performs an important function in talent growth. Repeated follow of particular passages, scales, and arpeggios reinforces technical expertise and builds muscle reminiscence. The handy entry supplied by the digital PDF encourages constant and common follow, maximizing the advantages of repetition. This constant engagement reinforces studying and accelerates the event of technical proficiency. Moreover, common overview of beforehand discovered materials helps preserve acquired expertise and prevents regression.

  • Listening and Aural Coaching

    Lively listening to recordings of the items in Guide 2, available within the digital age, develops aural expertise and informs musical interpretation. College students ought to hear attentively to skilled recordings, specializing in nuances of phrasing, dynamics, and articulation. This aural immersion cultivates a deeper understanding of the musical type and informs their very own taking part in. Listening additionally helps internalize the musical language and develop a way of musicality that extends past technical execution. This aural coaching, mixed with targeted follow, ends in a extra knowledgeable and expressive efficiency.

See also  7+ Best Jason Lee Photography Books & More

These follow methods, utilized persistently and thoughtfully, rework the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 PDF from a static assortment of musical notation right into a dynamic software for musical development. By approaching follow with intention and using efficient methods, college students develop not solely technical proficiency but in addition a deeper appreciation for the expressive energy of music. The digital format enhances these methods, providing flexibility, accessibility, and alternatives for customized studying. This mixture of efficient follow methods and accessible digital sources empowers college students to attain their full musical potential.

7. Parental Involvement

Parental involvement is integral to the Suzuki Methodology and considerably impacts a scholar’s expertise with the Suzuki Cello Guide 2, significantly when utilizing the digital PDF model. This lively participation extends past mere encouragement; it encompasses making a supportive studying atmosphere, facilitating follow, and fostering a lifelong love of music. The guardian’s function transcends that of a passive observer, remodeling them into an lively participant within the kid’s musical journey.

  • Dwelling Apply Steering

    Dad and mom function house follow companions, guiding college students by means of assigned workouts and items from the digital PDF. This day by day interplay reinforces the teachings discovered with the instructor and ensures constant engagement with the fabric. Dad and mom assist set up an everyday follow routine, offering construction and accountability. For instance, a guardian may assist a toddler arrange their follow area, making certain correct posture and instrument place, or information them by means of tough passages in a chunk from Guide 2 utilizing the digital rating.

  • Making a Supportive Setting

    Dad and mom domesticate a optimistic and inspiring environment at house, fostering a love of music and the cello. This contains attending classes, actively listening to the kid’s taking part in, and offering optimistic reinforcement. A supportive atmosphere minimizes efficiency anxiousness and nurtures intrinsic motivation. As an illustration, a guardian may create a devoted follow area free from distractions or arrange listening classes that includes cello music, exposing the kid to a wider vary of repertoire past Guide 2.

  • Facilitating Technological Integration

    With the digital PDF model, dad and mom play an important function in navigating the expertise and making certain seamless entry to the fabric. This contains managing digital recordsdata, troubleshooting technical points, and using software program options like playback and annotation instruments. For instance, a guardian may assist the kid entry the PDF on their pill, modify the display screen brightness for optimum viewing, or use annotation options to mark fingerings and bowings on the digital rating.

  • Nurturing Lengthy-Time period Musical Development

    Parental involvement extends past the instant follow classes, shaping the kid’s long-term musical growth. By actively taking part of their musical journey, dad and mom instill a lifelong appreciation for music and help their continued development as musicians. This ongoing help encourages constant follow, participation in group classes and performances, and a deeper engagement with the musical group. This fosters a love of music that extends past the confines of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 and nurtures a lifelong pursuit of musical expression.

Parental involvement, due to this fact, types the cornerstone of the Suzuki Methodology’s effectiveness, significantly when using sources just like the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 PDF. By actively taking part of their kid’s musical growth, dad and mom contribute not solely to their technical progress but in addition to their general appreciation and pleasure of music. This collaborative method, fostered by parental involvement, transforms the educational course of right into a shared journey of musical discovery and private development. The digital format of Guide 2 additional enhances this collaborative side, offering accessible and versatile instruments for each scholar and guardian.

8. Musical Improvement

Musical growth, throughout the context of using the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 in digital PDF format, encompasses a multifaceted course of extending past technical proficiency. It includes cultivating aural expertise, fostering musicality, and nurturing a lifelong appreciation for music. This holistic method shapes the coed’s musical journey, remodeling them from a novice right into a well-rounded musician.

  • Aural Abilities Improvement

    Creating a eager ear is essential for musical development. The Suzuki Methodology, as utilized by means of the Cello Guide 2, emphasizes listening and aural coaching. Common publicity to recordings of the repertoire, readily accessible by means of the digital format, hones listening expertise and internalizes musical nuances. This aural coaching allows college students to discern refined variations in pitch, rhythm, and dynamics, informing their very own taking part in and fostering a deeper understanding of musical expression.

  • Musicality and Interpretation

    Technical proficiency serves as a basis for musical expression. The fastidiously curated repertoire in Guide 2, encompassing people songs and classical items, supplies alternatives for college kids to discover phrasing, dynamics, and articulation, fostering musicality and interpretive expertise. The digital format, with its playback and annotation options, permits for detailed evaluation and experimentation with totally different interpretive approaches, encouraging customized expression and inventive growth.

  • Music Appreciation and Cultural Understanding

    Publicity to a various vary of musical types, even throughout the targeted scope of Guide 2, cultivates an appreciation for music from totally different eras and cultures. This broadened musical horizon enriches the coed’s understanding of musical historical past and context. The digital format facilitates entry to supplementary sources, equivalent to recordings of various performances and historic details about the composers, additional enhancing music appreciation and cultural understanding.

  • Lifelong Musical Engagement

    The Suzuki Methodology, carried out by means of sources just like the Cello Guide 2 PDF, goals to foster a lifelong love of music. By nurturing a optimistic and supportive studying atmosphere, emphasizing musical enjoyment, and creating a stable technical basis, the strategy encourages continued musical engagement past the confines of the curriculum. The readily accessible digital format promotes constant follow and unbiased exploration, contributing to a lifelong journey of musical studying and pleasure.

See also  6+ Best Blue Sisters Book Reviews (2024)

Musical growth, throughout the context of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 PDF, represents a holistic and transformative course of. By integrating technical growth with aural coaching, musical interpretation, and cultural understanding, this method nurtures well-rounded musicians outfitted with the talents and keenness to interact with music all through their lives. The digital format enhances this developmental course of by offering accessible instruments and sources that empower college students and educators alike.

Regularly Requested Questions

This part addresses frequent inquiries relating to the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 in digital PDF format, offering readability and steering for potential customers.

Query 1: Are digital PDF variations of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 thought-about legit studying sources in comparison with printed editions?

Digital variations obtained from licensed sources are equal to printed editions in content material. The pedagogical worth stays constant no matter format. Nonetheless, verifying the supply’s legitimacy is essential to make sure correct musical notation and adherence to copyright laws.

Query 2: What are some great benefits of utilizing a digital PDF model for practising and studying?

Digital variations provide a number of benefits, together with portability, searchability, annotation capabilities, and integration with music software program. These options improve the educational expertise, providing flexibility and customized follow choices.

Query 3: Are there any potential drawbacks or limitations related to the digital PDF format?

Potential drawbacks embrace gadget dependence, potential compatibility points throughout totally different gadgets and software program, and the necessity for digital literacy. Nonetheless, these drawbacks are sometimes outweighed by the advantages of digital accessibility and suppleness.

Query 4: How does the usage of a digital PDF model align with the rules of the Suzuki Methodology?

The digital format aligns properly with the Suzuki Methodology’s emphasis on parental involvement and residential follow. The portability and accessibility of digital variations facilitate parental steering and constant follow, supporting core rules of the strategy.

Query 5: Can the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 PDF be used successfully for self-teaching, or is instructor steering important?

Whereas the digital format supplies accessible studying sources, instructor steering stays extremely advisable. A certified Suzuki instructor supplies customized instruction, suggestions on method, and steering on musical interpretation, essential for efficient studying and musical growth. The PDF serves as a supplementary software, enhancing the teacher-student studying dynamic.

Query 6: The place can legit digital PDF variations of the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 be obtained?

Reputable digital variations ought to be bought from licensed retailers or respected on-line music shops. Verifying the supply’s legitimacy ensures copyright compliance and the integrity of the musical content material. Keep away from unauthorized downloads or copies, which can comprise inaccurate notation or infringe on copyright legal guidelines.

Cautious consideration of those ceaselessly requested questions supplies a complete understanding of the benefits and potential limitations of utilizing the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 in digital PDF format. Knowledgeable decision-making ensures an optimum studying expertise for aspiring cellists.

The next sections will delve into additional sensible concerns and sources associated to the Suzuki Cello Guide 2 and its utilization throughout the broader context of cello schooling.

Suggestions for Efficient Use of Suzuki Cello Guide 2 Digital Sources

Optimizing the educational course of with digital variations of Suzuki Cello Guide 2 requires a structured method. The next ideas present sensible steering for maximizing the advantages of this useful useful resource.

Tip 1: Set up a Constant Apply Routine: Common, targeted follow classes are essential for constant progress. Leveraging the portability of digital sources permits for follow in numerous settings, selling constant engagement with the fabric. Integrating follow into day by day routines fosters self-discipline and maximizes studying outcomes.

Tip 2: Make the most of Annotation Options: Digital PDFs provide annotation instruments that improve studying. Marking fingerings, bowings, and different musical notations instantly on the rating personalizes the educational expertise and facilitates environment friendly follow. These digital annotations present a visible file of follow progress and areas requiring additional consideration.

Tip 3: Combine Multimedia Sources: Complement follow classes with available on-line sources. Accessing recordings of the items in Guide 2 supplies aural fashions and informs musical interpretation. Video tutorials and on-line masterclasses provide useful insights into cello method and efficiency follow.

Tip 4: Optimize Digital Gadget Utilization: Correct gadget setup enhances the educational expertise. Adjusting display screen brightness, utilizing acceptable stands, and minimizing distractions optimize focus and engagement throughout follow classes. Using options equivalent to split-screen viewing permits simultaneous entry to the rating and tutorial movies.

Tip 5: Collaborate with Academics and Friends: Digital sources facilitate collaboration and suggestions. Sharing annotated scores with academics permits for distant steering and customized instruction. Partaking in on-line boards or digital follow classes with friends fosters a way of group and supplies alternatives for peer studying.

Tip 6: Preserve Digital File Group: Organized digital recordsdata streamline the educational course of. Creating devoted folders for various items, follow notes, and supplementary supplies ensures quick access and environment friendly follow administration. Often backing up digital recordsdata prevents information loss and preserves useful studying sources.

Tip 7: Steadiness Display Time with Bodily Actions: Whereas digital sources improve studying, sustaining a stability with bodily actions is essential. Incorporating breaks, bodily workouts, and different offline actions promotes general well-being and prevents digital fatigue, optimizing studying effectiveness.

Constant utility of the following tips ensures that the digital model of Suzuki Cello Guide 2 turns into a strong software for musical development. These practices domesticate not solely technical proficiency but in addition a deeper appreciation for music and the cello.

The next concluding remarks will synthesize key takeaways and provide closing suggestions for embarking on a rewarding cello studying journey.

Conclusion

Exploration of the digital model of Suzuki Cello Guide 2 reveals its significance inside up to date cello pedagogy. Accessibility, portability, and integration with digital instruments improve its efficacy as a studying useful resource. Cautious consideration of pedagogical rules, follow methods, and parental involvement maximizes advantages derived from this materials. Technical growth, musical expression, and lifelong engagement with music characterize core outcomes facilitated by efficient utilization of this useful resource. Moreover, adherence to accessibility tips ensures inclusivity and broadens entry to music schooling.

The digital format’s transformative potential inside music schooling warrants continued exploration and considerate integration. Cultivating a nuanced understanding of pedagogical rules, mixed with efficient utilization of digital instruments, empowers aspiring cellists to embark on a rewarding journey of musical discovery and inventive expression. This pursuit enriches not solely particular person lives but in addition contributes to the colourful tapestry of musical heritage and cultural expression.

Leave a Comment