8+ Ramona Quimby, Age 8: Book Review


8+ Ramona Quimby, Age 8: Book Review

Beverly Cleary’s novel, the fourth within the Ramona collection, facilities on the experiences of a younger lady navigating the thrill and challenges of third grade. This installment portrays frequent childhood conditions, similar to coping with schoolwork, household dynamics, and the complexities of friendships, all by means of the lens of Ramona’s spirited and generally misunderstood perspective. A quintessential instance of youngsters’s literature, the narrative supplies younger readers with a relatable protagonist and explores themes of resilience, development, and the significance of household.

Printed in 1981, this explicit entry within the collection holds a particular place within the hearts of many readers. It captures the essence of childhood with humor and sensitivity, providing enduring classes about empathy and understanding. The e-book’s enduring reputation stems from its means to resonate with each kids and adults, bridging generational gaps by means of shared experiences and timeless themes. Its contribution to kids’s literature has been vital, serving to to form the panorama of practical fiction for younger audiences.

Additional exploration will delve into particular features of the narrative, character improvement, vital reception, and the lasting legacy of this beloved kids’s e-book.

1. Third-grade experiences

The portrayal of third-grade experiences kinds a central theme in Beverly Cleary’s Ramona Quimby, Age 8. The novel affords a sensible depiction of the challenges and triumphs encountered by younger college students, making a relatable narrative for readers. Analyzing particular aspects of those experiences supplies deeper perception into the e-book’s affect and enduring attraction.

  • Classroom Dynamics

    The e-book explores the complexities of classroom dynamics, together with interactions with academics, peer relationships, and navigating the social hierarchy of elementary faculty. Ramona’s struggles with seat assignments, misunderstandings together with her instructor, and interactions with classmates like Susan reveal the on a regular basis realities of a third-grade classroom. These experiences resonate with readers who’ve confronted comparable conditions, fostering a way of connection and understanding.

  • Educational Challenges

    Educational challenges, similar to studying cursive writing, spelling checks, and tackling new topics, are distinguished parts of Ramona’s third-grade journey. The e-book portrays the frustration and triumphs related to these challenges, highlighting the significance of perseverance and the help of educators. Ramona’s struggles with “d corridor” and her eventual success in mastering cursive exemplify the standard educational hurdles confronted by younger learners.

  • Growing Independence

    The narrative additionally touches upon the event of independence in third grade. Ramona’s want to tackle extra accountability and her makes an attempt to navigate faculty and social conditions independently showcase this significant stage of childhood improvement. Cases like strolling to high school alone and managing her lunch cash reveal the rising independence anticipated of eight-year-olds.

  • Social and Emotional Development

    Ramona Quimby, Age 8 highlights the social and emotional development that happens throughout this pivotal 12 months. Ramona’s experiences with friendship, coping with disappointments, and studying to know totally different views contribute to her emotional improvement. Her interactions with Yard Ape and her evolving relationship with Howie Kemp reveal the complexities of childhood friendships and the event of empathy.

These interconnected aspects of third-grade experiences contribute to the general realism and relatability of Ramona Quimby, Age 8. By exploring these frequent childhood conditions, Cleary supplies readers with a relatable and interesting narrative that captures the essence of this formative 12 months. The e-book’s enduring reputation stems from its means to precisely and sensitively painting the challenges and triumphs of navigating third grade, resonating with readers throughout generations.

2. Household Dynamics

Household dynamics play a vital position in Ramona Quimby, Age 8, shaping Ramona’s experiences and contributing to the novel’s practical portrayal of childhood. Exploring these dynamics supplies perception into Ramona’s character improvement and the complexities of household relationships.

  • Monetary Pressure

    The Quimby household faces monetary challenges, impacting each day life and creating stress. Mr. Quimby’s return to varsity and subsequent job search contributes to monetary instability, impacting household meals and creating a way of fear for Ramona. This practical portrayal of economic pressure provides depth to the narrative, reflecting the experiences of many households.

  • Parental Roles and Obligations

    The division of labor and tasks inside the Quimby family supplies perception into the dynamics between mother and father and kids. Mrs. Quimby’s position as the first caregiver and Mr. Quimby’s efforts to contribute whereas pursuing his schooling spotlight the challenges of balancing work, household, and private aspirations. These portrayals supply practical depictions of parental roles and their affect on kids.

  • Sibling Relationships

    Ramona’s relationship together with her older sister, Beezus, is a big facet of the household dynamic. Their interactions, marked by each battle and affection, replicate the frequent complexities of sibling relationships. Beezus’s teenage struggles and Ramona’s makes an attempt to realize her approval contribute to the practical portrayal of sibling dynamics.

  • Communication and Understanding

    The household’s communication patterns and makes an attempt to know one another’s views contribute to the general portrayal of household dynamics. Cases of miscommunication and the eventual decision of conflicts spotlight the significance of empathy and open communication inside households. Ramona’s efforts to know her mother and father’ worries and their makes an attempt to handle her issues reveal the complexities of familial communication.

These interconnected household dynamics contribute considerably to the narrative of Ramona Quimby, Age 8. By exploring these dynamics, Cleary supplies readers with a sensible and relatable portrayal of household life, highlighting the challenges, joys, and complexities of navigating childhood inside a household unit. The e-book’s enduring attraction stems from its means to seize the nuances of those relationships, resonating with readers who acknowledge comparable dynamics in their very own lives.

3. Childhood Friendships

Ramona Quimby, Age 8 affords a nuanced exploration of childhood friendships, highlighting their complexities and affect on a younger lady’s improvement. These relationships, typically fraught with misunderstandings, shifting alliances, and evolving dynamics, play a pivotal position in shaping Ramona’s experiences and contributing to the novel’s practical portrayal of childhood.

  • Navigating Social Dynamics

    Ramona navigates the intricate social dynamics of the classroom and playground, encountering various friendship types and challenges. Her interactions with classmates like Susan, who embodies the position of the “excellent” scholar, and the boisterous Yard Ape, reveal the varied personalities kids encounter and the challenges of discovering one’s place inside a social group. This mirrors real-life experiences the place kids study to navigate social hierarchies and negotiate relationships with totally different personalities.

  • The Worth of Shared Experiences

    Shared experiences kind the inspiration of many childhood friendships, and this theme is clear in Ramona’s interactions together with her friends. From classroom tasks and playground video games to shared anxieties about faculty and household, these shared experiences contribute to the formation and strengthening of bonds. This displays the real-world significance of shared actions and experiences in fostering connections between kids.

  • Misunderstandings and Battle Decision

    Misunderstandings and conflicts are inevitable in childhood friendships, and Ramona Quimby, Age 8 portrays these challenges realistically. Ramona’s interactions with Howie Kemp, marked by preliminary mistrust and eventual understanding, reveal the complexities of navigating disagreements and the significance of communication in resolving conflicts. This mirrors the developmental technique of studying to handle battle and construct stronger relationships by means of communication and empathy.

  • Evolving Relationships

    Childhood friendships are sometimes characterised by their evolving nature, as kids develop and alter. Ramona’s relationships together with her classmates shift all through the novel, reflecting the fluid nature of friendships at this age. As kids develop new pursuits and navigate totally different social conditions, friendships can strengthen, weaken, or remodel, mirroring the pure development of childhood relationships.

See also  6+ Insights: Book of Enoch Chapter 30 Demystified

The exploration of childhood friendships in Ramona Quimby, Age 8 provides depth and realism to the narrative. By showcasing the assorted aspects of those relationships, Cleary supplies readers with a relatable and insightful portrayal of the challenges and rewards of navigating friendships throughout childhood. These experiences contribute considerably to Ramona’s development and understanding of herself and the world round her, in the end enriching the general narrative and resonating with readers who’ve skilled comparable dynamics in their very own lives.

4. Ramona’s Perspective

Ramona Quimby, Age 8 distinguishes itself by means of its narrative perspective, firmly rooted in Ramona’s eight-year-old viewpoint. This attitude shapes the reader’s understanding of occasions, providing a novel lens by means of which childhood experiences are filtered. Ramona’s interpretations, typically differing from grownup views, present perception into the complexities of navigating the world as a younger baby. For instance, the seemingly minor incident of receiving a barely broken owl sticker turns into a significant supply of frustration for Ramona, highlighting how seemingly small occasions can maintain vital weight in a toddler’s world. This resonates with readers who recall comparable childhood experiences the place perceived injustices felt monumental.

The narrative’s adherence to Ramona’s perspective permits readers entry to her unfiltered ideas and feelings. Her inside monologue reveals her anxieties, joys, and frustrations, fostering empathy and understanding within the reader. This intimate portrayal of childhood thought processes contributes to the e-book’s realism and enduring attraction. The narrative does not draw back from portraying Ramona’s flaws, similar to her impulsivity and occasional misunderstandings, additional enhancing the authenticity of her character. Contemplate how Ramona misinterprets Mrs. Kemp’s remark about “feeding the meter,” revealing the literal interpretations frequent in younger kids. This not solely provides humor but in addition supplies perception into the kid’s creating cognitive talents.

By constantly sustaining Ramona’s perspective, Beverly Cleary crafts a story that resonates deeply with readers of all ages. The e-book’s success lies in its means to move readers again to their very own childhoods, reminding them of the depth of feelings, the importance of seemingly small occasions, and the distinctive perspective that shapes a toddler’s understanding of the world. The challenges Ramona faces, from educational pressures to social dynamics, are offered with an authenticity that stems straight from this fastidiously crafted narrative perspective. This understanding of the significance of perspective contributes considerably to the e-book’s lasting affect and its continued relevance in kids’s literature.

5. Real looking Fiction

Ramona Quimby, Age 8 stands as a main instance of practical fiction inside kids’s literature. This style, characterised by its portrayal of relatable characters and conditions, performs a vital position in connecting younger readers with literature. The narrative’s grounding within the on a regular basis experiences of a 3rd grader enhances its affect and contributes to its enduring reputation. Exploring the connection between practical fiction and this particular work reveals its contribution to the style and its lasting affect.

  • On a regular basis Life Depiction

    Real looking fiction emphasizes the depiction of on a regular basis life, capturing the nuances of peculiar experiences. Ramona Quimby, Age 8 excels on this facet, portraying acquainted conditions similar to faculty days, household dinners, and sibling squabbles. These relatable eventualities create a way of familiarity for readers, drawing them into Ramona’s world and fostering a connection together with her experiences. This correct depiction of each day life reinforces the style’s concentrate on practical portrayals and strengthens the e-book’s connection to its readers.

  • Character Relatability

    Characters in practical fiction possess relatable traits, flaws, and motivations. Ramona, together with her impulsive nature, occasional misunderstandings, and earnest wishes, embodies this relatability. Readers acknowledge features of themselves or their friends in Ramona’s conduct, making a stronger emotional connection to the narrative. This character relatability is a trademark of practical fiction, enhancing reader engagement and fostering empathy.

  • Age-Acceptable Themes

    Real looking fiction typically explores age-appropriate themes related to the target market. Ramona Quimby, Age 8 delves into themes pertinent to younger kids, together with navigating faculty, household dynamics, and the complexities of friendships. These themes resonate deeply with younger readers, offering them with a literary mirror reflecting their very own experiences and challenges. The exploration of such themes reinforces the style’s dedication to portraying practical conditions confronted by younger individuals.

  • Emotional Resonance

    Real looking fiction strives to evoke emotional resonance in readers, permitting them to attach with the characters’ emotions and experiences. Ramona Quimby, Age 8 achieves this by means of its portrayal of Ramona’s emotional journey. Readers expertise her joys, frustrations, and anxieties alongside her, fostering empathy and understanding. This emotional depth additional distinguishes the e-book as a robust instance of practical fiction, demonstrating the style’s means to attach with readers on an emotional degree.

By successfully using the weather of practical fiction, Ramona Quimby, Age 8 solidifies its place as a traditional inside the style. The e-book’s concentrate on on a regular basis experiences, relatable characters, age-appropriate themes, and emotional resonance creates a robust reference to readers. This connection contributes to the e-book’s enduring reputation and reinforces its significance inside kids’s literature. The practical portrayal of Ramona’s world permits younger readers to see themselves mirrored in literature, validating their experiences and fostering a love of studying.

6. Beverly Cleary’s Writing

Beverly Cleary’s distinct writing type considerably contributes to the enduring attraction of Ramona Quimby, Age 8. Her means to seize the nuances of childhood thought processes and experiences, mixed with a transparent and interesting prose, distinguishes her work inside kids’s literature. This exploration delves into the connection between Cleary’s writing type and the particular affect it has on this novel.

See also  8+ Best PSAT Prep Books: 2024 Edition

Cleary’s masterful use of voice is central to her success. The narrative voice constantly stays trustworthy to Ramona’s eight-year-old perspective, permitting readers entry to her unfiltered ideas and feelings. This creates a way of intimacy and immediacy, drawing readers into Ramona’s world and fostering empathy for her experiences. The humor arises organically from Ramona’s interpretations of the world round her, typically contrasting the grownup perspective with a toddler’s extra literal understanding. For instance, Ramona’s misinterpretation of the “d corridor” as a mysterious and presumably harmful place highlights this comedic distinction whereas concurrently revealing the constraints of a kid’s understanding. This means to search out humor in on a regular basis conditions is a trademark of Cleary’s writing.

Past humor, Cleary’s writing tackles advanced themes with sensitivity and nuance. The portrayal of the Quimby household’s monetary struggles, whereas dealt with with age-appropriate language, does not draw back from the realities of financial hardship. This trustworthy portrayal provides depth to the narrative and permits younger readers to grapple with advanced points in a protected and relatable context. Equally, the exploration of sibling rivalry and evolving friendships resonates with readers who acknowledge these common experiences inside their very own lives. Cleary’s means to steadiness humor with severe themes contributes to the e-book’s lasting affect. The easy prose, devoid of pointless embellishment, permits the characters and their experiences to take heart stage. This directness, mixed with fastidiously chosen particulars, creates a vivid and interesting studying expertise, guaranteeing that the main target stays on Ramona’s emotional journey and the challenges she faces. This mixture of humor, practical portrayals, and accessible language solidifies Ramona Quimby, Age 8‘s place as a beloved traditional in kids’s literature, showcasing the facility of Cleary’s distinct writing type.

7. 1981 publication

The publication of Ramona Quimby, Age 8 in 1981 situates the novel inside a particular sociocultural context. Analyzing this context supplies insights into the e-book’s reception, its relevance to up to date readers, and its enduring legacy inside kids’s literature. Understanding the historic backdrop surrounding the publication date enhances appreciation for the work’s affect and enduring reputation.

  • Societal Values and Tendencies

    1981 marked a interval of transition in American society, with evolving household constructions and shifting cultural norms. The e-book’s portrayal of a working mom and a father returning to varsity mirrored these altering dynamics, resonating with households navigating comparable experiences. Analyzing the societal values and traits of the time illuminates the e-book’s relevance to up to date readers and its means to seize the zeitgeist of the early Nineteen Eighties.

  • Kids’s Literature Panorama

    The panorama of youngsters’s literature in 1981 supplies a backdrop towards which to evaluate the e-book’s contribution to the style. The prevalence of practical fiction aimed toward younger readers and the themes explored in up to date kids’s books supply a comparative lens for understanding the e-book’s distinctive contribution. Analyzing the present literary panorama highlights how Ramona Quimby, Age 8 match inside and probably challenged prevailing traits in kids’s literature on the time.

  • Preliminary Reception and Important Response

    Investigating the preliminary reception and significant response to the e-book upon its 1981 launch affords insights into its early affect. Critiques, awards, and early reader reactions present priceless context for understanding how the e-book was perceived upon publication. This evaluation can illuminate the elements contributing to its subsequent reputation and enduring legacy.

  • Technological and Cultural Context

    The technological and cultural panorama of 1981 differed considerably from the current day. Contemplating the absence of widespread web entry and the prevalence of various types of media consumption supplies context for understanding the e-book’s attain and affect. Analyzing this context permits for a deeper appreciation of the e-book’s enduring relevance in a vastly totally different technological and cultural panorama.

Analyzing the sociocultural, literary, and technological context surrounding the 1981 publication of Ramona Quimby, Age 8 enriches understanding of the e-book’s significance. Connecting these contextual elements with the narrative’s themes and characters supplies a deeper appreciation for its lasting affect on kids’s literature and its continued resonance with readers throughout generations. Understanding the historic backdrop permits for a extra nuanced interpretation of the e-book’s themes and a higher appreciation for its enduring legacy.

8. Enduring Reputation

Ramona Quimby, Age 8, revealed in 1981, maintains a exceptional degree of recognition many years later. This enduring attraction stems from a mixture of things that resonate with readers throughout generations, solidifying its standing as a beloved traditional in kids’s literature. Exploring the important thing elements contributing to this sustained reputation supplies insights into the e-book’s lasting affect and its continued relevance for up to date audiences.

  • Relatable Character and Experiences

    Ramona’s character, flawed but endearing, resonates with readers who acknowledge their very own childhood experiences in her struggles and triumphs. Navigating faculty, household dynamics, and friendships are common themes that transcend generational gaps, permitting readers of all ages to attach with Ramona’s emotional journey. Her reactions to on a regular basis conditions, from the frustration of a ruined faculty image to the joy of a small triumph, mirror the emotional panorama of childhood, fostering a way of familiarity and connection.

  • Timeless Themes

    The e-book explores timeless themes of household, friendship, and private development, guaranteeing its continued relevance for up to date readers. Whereas the cultural context might have shifted for the reason that e-book’s publication, the underlying challenges and joys of childhood stay fixed. Themes of resilience, navigating social dynamics, and looking for independence resonate with readers no matter their background or period. This universality contributes to the e-book’s enduring attraction and its means to attach with readers throughout generations.

  • Beverly Cleary’s Writing Fashion

    Cleary’s clear, partaking prose and her means to seize the nuances of a kid’s perspective contribute considerably to the e-book’s enduring reputation. Her writing type avoids condescension whereas remaining accessible to younger readers, putting a steadiness that appeals to each kids and adults. The humor, typically derived from Ramona’s misinterpretations and misunderstandings, stays recent and interesting, additional enhancing the e-book’s readability and attraction.

  • Nostalgia and Intergenerational Connections

    Ramona Quimby, Age 8 typically serves as a nostalgic touchstone for grownup readers, evoking fond reminiscences of their very own childhood studying experiences. This nostalgia typically results in mother and father and grandparents sharing the e-book with youthful generations, making a cycle of readership that contributes to the e-book’s enduring presence in common tradition. This intergenerational connection reinforces the e-book’s lasting affect and ensures its continued relevance for brand spanking new generations of readers.

See also  6+ Magical Christmas Pop-Up Books for Kids

These interconnected elements contribute to the enduring reputation of Ramona Quimby, Age 8. The mix of relatable characters and experiences, timeless themes, partaking writing type, and nostalgic connections ensures the e-book’s continued relevance within the ever-evolving panorama of youngsters’s literature. Ramona’s journey continues to resonate with readers, solidifying the e-book’s place as a cherished traditional and a testomony to the facility of capturing the essence of childhood.

Incessantly Requested Questions

This part addresses frequent inquiries concerning Beverly Cleary’s Ramona Quimby, Age 8, offering additional insights into the novel’s themes, characters, and affect.

Query 1: What are the first themes explored in “Ramona Quimby, Age 8”?

The novel explores themes of household relationships, monetary challenges, childhood friendships, navigating faculty experiences, and the complexities of rising up. Ramona’s journey by means of third grade highlights the challenges and triumphs of this pivotal 12 months, providing readers relatable conditions and priceless life classes.

Query 2: How does “Ramona Quimby, Age 8” contribute to the style of practical fiction?

The novel’s practical portrayal of on a regular basis life, relatable characters, and age-appropriate themes solidifies its contribution to practical fiction. Ramona’s experiences resonate with readers who acknowledge comparable conditions in their very own lives, strengthening the connection between literature and private expertise. The trustworthy depiction of household dynamics, faculty challenges, and social interactions reinforces the style’s dedication to portraying practical conditions.

Query 3: Why does “Ramona Quimby, Age 8” stay common many years after its publication?

The e-book’s enduring reputation stems from the timeless themes of household, friendship, and private development, which proceed to resonate with readers throughout generations. Ramona’s relatable character, coupled with Beverly Cleary’s partaking writing type, ensures the e-book’s continued relevance in up to date society. The nostalgic connection many readers really feel in direction of the e-book additional contributes to its enduring attraction.

Query 4: How does Ramona’s perspective form the narrative?

The narrative is firmly anchored in Ramona’s eight-year-old perspective, offering readers with distinctive insights into her ideas, emotions, and interpretations of the world. This attitude shapes the narrative by highlighting the importance of seemingly small occasions in a toddler’s life and emphasizing the emotional depth of childhood experiences.

Query 5: What’s the significance of the Quimby household’s monetary struggles within the novel?

The Quimby household’s monetary challenges add a layer of realism to the narrative, reflecting the experiences of many households. This portrayal affords younger readers an age-appropriate understanding of financial hardship and its affect on household dynamics, including depth and complexity to the story.

Query 6: How does Beverly Cleary’s writing type contribute to the e-book’s success?

Cleary’s clear, partaking prose, mixed together with her means to seize the nuances of a kid’s perspective, contributes considerably to the e-book’s success. Her writing type avoids condescension whereas remaining accessible to younger readers, putting a steadiness that appeals to a broad viewers. The humor, typically derived from Ramona’s misunderstandings and misinterpretations, additional enhances the e-book’s readability and attraction.

Understanding these features of Ramona Quimby, Age 8 supplies a complete appreciation for its contribution to kids’s literature. The e-book’s enduring reputation speaks to its means to attach with readers on an emotional degree and supply priceless insights into the complexities of childhood.

Additional exploration may delve into particular character analyses, comparative research with different works within the collection, or the e-book’s cultural affect.

Suggestions for Navigating Third Grade Impressed by Ramona Quimby

Beverly Cleary’s Ramona Quimby, Age 8 affords priceless insights into the challenges and triumphs of navigating third grade. Whereas fictional, Ramona’s experiences present relatable eventualities and potential methods for younger learners and their households.

Tip 1: Embrace Imperfection: Ramona’s mishaps, from “d corridor” to the “boingy” curls, remind one which errors are a part of studying. Concentrate on effort and resilience fairly than striving for unrealistic perfection.

Tip 2: Talk Brazenly: Misunderstandings between Ramona and her household and instructor spotlight the significance of clear communication. Encouraging open dialogue between kids, mother and father, and educators can forestall pointless frustration and foster stronger relationships.

Tip 3: Discover Humor in Challenges: Ramona’s means to search out humor in tough conditions demonstrates a priceless coping mechanism. Encouraging a lighthearted strategy to challenges can scale back stress and promote a optimistic outlook.

Tip 4: Worth Individuality: Ramona’s distinctive perspective and quirky character are celebrated all through the novel. Encouraging kids to embrace their individuality fosters self-confidence and a way of belonging.

Tip 5: Search Help When Wanted: Ramona depends on her household and instructor for help throughout difficult instances. Highlighting the significance of looking for assist and steering when going through difficulties normalizes this important facet of private development.

Tip 6: Persevere By means of Difficulties: Ramona’s persistence in studying cursive, regardless of preliminary struggles, emphasizes the significance of perseverance. Encouraging a development mindset and celebrating small victories might help kids overcome educational and social challenges.

Tip 7: Rejoice Small Victories: Ramona’s pleasure over seemingly small accomplishments, like lastly mastering cursive, reminds one to understand and have fun incremental progress. Acknowledging these small steps fosters motivation and reinforces a optimistic studying expertise.

By reflecting on Ramona’s experiences, kids and households can achieve priceless instruments for navigating the challenges and celebrating the thrill of third grade. These classes prolong past the classroom, providing insights into constructing resilience, fostering communication, and appreciating particular person strengths.

The following pointers supply sensible methods for making use of the teachings discovered from Ramona Quimby, Age 8 to real-life conditions. The next conclusion will summarize the important thing takeaways and reiterate the e-book’s lasting affect on kids’s literature.

Conclusion

Ramona Quimby, Age 8 stands as a testomony to Beverly Cleary’s means to seize the essence of childhood. This exploration has delved into the multifaceted features of the novel, from Ramona’s perspective and the complexities of third-grade experiences to the portrayal of household dynamics and the importance of practical fiction. The enduring reputation of this work stems from its relatable characters, timeless themes, and interesting writing type, solidifying its place as a beloved traditional inside kids’s literature. Evaluation of the e-book’s 1981 publication context additional enriches understanding of its affect and continued relevance.

The novel’s exploration of childhood experiences affords priceless insights into navigating the challenges and celebrating the triumphs of rising up. Ramona Quimby, Age 8 continues to resonate with readers throughout generations, reminding one of many significance of empathy, resilience, and the facility of connecting with genuine portrayals of childhood. Additional scholarly investigation may delve into the e-book’s cultural affect, its contribution to the evolution of youngsters’s literature, and its enduring legacy inside the broader literary panorama.

Leave a Comment